A Test Of Representative Democracy

I haven’t posted anything about the actual passage, and now the signature into law, of the “health care reform” legislation.  We are now learning about heretofore undiscussed provisions of the massive legislation — like the provision that requires disclosures of calories on the menus of restaurants, the provisions that exempt certain congressional staffers from certain aspects of the new law, and the special projects and funding agreements that secured some votes in the House of Representatives — and I have no doubt that we will learn more along those lines in the days to come. 

In any case, the “health care reform” bill is now a law, and Americans need to decide how to deal with it.  This country is a representative democracy.  The underlying concept of that form of government is that we are too big to have national plebiscites on every issue.  Instead, individual citizens elect representatives who then cast the determinative votes on legislation. Once they are in office, we must trust our elected representatives to exercise their best judgment, based on their knowledge of the issues and the interests of their constituents, in deciding how to vote.

In our system, therefore, the Members of Congress who voted in favor of the “health care reform” legislation had every right to do so.  They are not obligated to follow the currents of popular opinion or the findings of the latest poll.  Similarly, though, voters have every right to vote against a Member of Congress on the basis of their voting record.

The question now is how Americans will react come November, and whether they will vote out those Congressmen and Senators who voted for the “health care reform” legislation.  I know that many people are infuriated at what Congress has done.  Tonight, for example, as Kish and I were walking to the library we were stopped by a neighbor who vented for a good five minutes about the bill and the process by which it was enacted.  Will that neighbor have the same passion after months have passed?  Will she contribute to campaigns and canvas for candidates who vow to work to repeal the new law?  Only time will tell — but I expect we’ll be hearing a lot more about the “health care reform” legislation in the coming months, from the media and our friends and neighbors.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s