Ohio State fans are happy because the Buckeyes vaulted up two spots, to sixth place, in the college football playoff rankings announced last night. That’s certainly better than heading in the other direction, but there’s just something a bit . . . unsettling about this whole process.
The Buckeyes, who won on Saturday, passed higher-ranked Arizona State, which lost. I get that. But the Buckeyes also moved past Baylor, which had a bye week. Why? Who knows? And for many Ohio State fans, the answer is: who cares? As long as the Buckeyes are moving up the chain and still have a chance to make the first college football playoff, they’re happy campers.
But seriously . . . why should Ohio State leapfrog Baylor? The answer, I think, is that the 12-member selection panel that figures out the rankings is filled with people that aren’t much different from the rest of us. They’re aware of win-loss records, but they’re not prone to some purportedly scientific analysis of relative strength of schedule, common opponents, and other quasi-scientific factors that the computer wizards have used to determine rankings in the past. Instead, the panel members are prone to out-of-sight, out-of-mind notions, winning pretty versus winning ugly, the presence of stars on teams, intriguing match-ups, and other attributes of the rest of us everyday football fans.
That means that, if the college football playoff continues in its current form, you’re going to see it affect how the game is scheduled and played. Late-season bye weeks that might cause you to drop a spot or two in the rankings will be eliminated. Teams will try to pile up the points to get the most impressive wins, which means that starters will continue to play in blowouts and might suffer injuries that otherwise would have been avoided. And you’d better hope that your team and your conference are getting pretty good, respectful coverage on ESPN and other college football venues.
All of these factors might work in Ohio State’s favor right now — no late-season byes, a schedule that is backloaded with games against good teams, a lot of scoring, and the interesting J.T. Barrett story — but it only works until it doesn’t. If the Buckeyes get out to a good lead against Indiana and keep Barrett in the game, we’ll know that Urban Meyer and his staff have learned some lessons from how the rankings are developed.