The Browns have hired a new head coach, the 13th full-time head coach in the team’s history. His name is Pat Shurmur. Shurmur was the offensive coordinator for the St. Louis Rams for the last two seasons, and before that he was the tight ends, offensive line, and quarterbacks coach with the Philadelphia Eagles. So, the Browns have gone with someone whose coaching background is exclusively on the offensive side of the ball.
No one who watched the Browns struggle offensively at the end of the season will question the need to focus on scoring points. That said, Shurmur’s resume is somewhat thin. Philadelphia was one of the best teams in the NFL when he was an assistant there, but it is hard to say how much of the Eagles’ offensive success was attributable to Shurmur as opposed to the head coach, the offensive coordinator, and the Eagles’ talented players. In evaluating Shurmur’s record, therefore, the focus should be on St. Louis, where Shurmur was the offensive coordinator for only two years. This past year, the Rams finished 7-9 and were not exactly an offensive juggernaut. The team ranked 21st in the NFL in passing yards and 25th in the league in rushing yards, and failed to score at least 20 points nine times. The main point on Shurmur’s resume may be that he coached a new quarterback, Sam Bradford, who had a good year for a rookie.
This is one of those situations where the fans simply have to trust the evaluation and judgment of team management on the fitness of the new head coach. There is nothing in Shurmur’s resume to indicate that he is an offensive wizard who can turn the Browns into a point-producing machine, but he may well have the qualities that are needed to make him a good NFL head coach. Shurmur was the pick of Mike Holmgren, who knows Shurmur and who was himself a successful head coach. We can reasonably expect that Holmgren considered whether Shurmur has the attributes that are crucial to head coaching success — such as the willingness to work incredibly hard, the ability to recruit and shape a team of assistant coaches who are themselves excellent coaches, the skill to spot talent that is available through free agency and the draft and to identify players who can positively fill gaps in the current team roster, the organizational savvy to structure a training camp that gets the team ready for the season, and the football knowledge to spot and then exploit weaknesses in opponents. The reality is that you cannot tell whether a coach will succeed in a particular time and place until they actually get that opportunity. No one who watched Bill Belichick coach the Browns in the early ’90s would have guessed that Belichick would later turn the New England Patriots into a mini-dynasty.
So, the question of Shurmur’s fitness must await the test of actual games. The question of his “fit” with the Browns’ players also will remain unanswered until then. The Browns’ best offensive players this year were a big running back, Peyton Hillis, and tight end Ben Watson. Rookie quarterback Colt McCoy showed some promise but stumbled at the end of the season, the offensive line was average, and the receiving corps aside from Watson was not NFL-caliber. Does Shurmur’s offensive scheme “fit” with Hillis and Watson, and if not does he have the flexibility to modify his scheme to accommodate their considerable talents? Or, will the Browns need to rebuild, again? The fact that Shurmur successfully coached a big back in the Rams’ Steven Jackson and that the Rams made significant use of a platoon of tight ends gives some cause for hope.
Browns fans can only pray that Shurmur has the attributes needed to turn around the sagging Browns franchise. The Cleveland Browns have been wandering aimlessly in the wilderness since their return to the NFL. During that period the team has often been an embarrassment to devoted Browns Backers. We can only hope that Holmgren and his hand-picked coach can lead the team to the promised land of the NFL playoffs and back to the record of consistent excellence that characterized the Cleveland Browns for decades.