The Biology Of Conscience

Scientists at Oxford have made a fascinating discovery about the human brain. They have identified an area called the lateral frontal pole that focuses on considering alternative courses of action and comparing them to what we’ve actually done. Even more intriguing, their work shows that there is no similar area in the brains of monkeys.

The study used MRI scanning techniques to map neural pathways within the brain and determine which areas are connected to the ventrolateral frontal cortex, which is the part of the brain involved with language and cognitive flexibility. The studies allowed the scientists to identify the location and function of the lateral frontal pole, a bundle of neurons described as the size and shape of a Brussels sprout.

What really makes us human? One essential characteristic is comparing what we actually did to what we could have done — and then pondering endlessly about what we should have done. The concept of choice, and the identification, evaluation, and comparison of choices by the lateral frontal pole, lies at the root of many of the higher attributes of humans, because the concept of choice and causation leads inevitably to the concept of right and wrong. Philosophy, morals, ethics, and religious beliefs all argue about which choices are right and which are wrong and what considerations should go into how we make those choices. Should we pursue individual pleasure? Should we always try to act in furtherance of the greatest societal good?

These notions are all wrapped up in what we broadly call a conscience — which apparently lurks in the lateral frontal pole. It’s what makes us feel guilty and second-guess ourselves. It’s why Scrooge dreamed of Marley’s ghost. And it’s fascinating that monkeys, which have brains that are generally similar to the human brain, lack the section of the brain that engages in such activity. They apparently can steal a piece of fruit, happily gobble it down, and sleep soundly that night without a second thought or pang of guilt.

The next time you toss and turn at night, unable to sleep because you wonder whether you did the right thing, you can be sure the neurons in your lateral frontal pole are firing and churning away. We’ve got choice, and the lateral frontal pole ensures that we must live with the consequences.

Advertisements

“Ohio’s Public Ivy”

If you’ve been in or around central Ohio recently, you’ve probably seen the signs or heard the radio spots.  They tout Miami University, in Oxford, Ohio, as “Ohio’s Public Ivy.”

IMG_4198I think Miami is a fine school.  Although I am a proud graduate of The Ohio State University, many of my high school friends went to Miami, as did my cousin and a number of my current and former co-workers.  Tucked in the southwest corner of the state, it’s a well-regarded school that has many satisfied and loyal graduates.

But . . . “Ohio’s Public Ivy”?  It’s kind of a strange slogan, isn’t it?  I suppose “Ivy League” schools are associated with academic excellence, and that’s what Miami’s campaign is trying to invoke.  But “Ivy League” schools also suggest privilege, and arrogance, and snobbery, and other qualities that don’t really fit all that well with a heartland state like Ohio.

And, let’s face it — “Ohio’s Public Ivy” has a bit of a desperate wannabe element to it.  Miami isn’t an Ivy League school, and won’t be, so why is it trying to trade on an Ivy League rep?  Why not just stand on your own, and be proud of where you are and what you are?

That’s why I like “The Ohio State University.”  I know the “The” drives some people crazy, but I think it sends a message about the school and its pride about what it is.  It’s not trying to be anything else.