Occasionally you’ll hear someone talk about how smart their dog is. The Brown Bear, for example, will rave about the intellectual abilities of standard poodles. The Soccer Goalie will brook no argument that border collies are the smartest breed around. And Russell argues that his dog Betty, who is not a purebred, is as quick-witted as they come.
As for us — well, our Lab Dusty was well trained and seemed reasonably bright, and Kasey, our poodle, was clever. Our Lab Penny? Well, she was generally amiable if sometimes stubborn, and always hungry.
Those of you who are convinced your dog is the next animal Einstein might be disappointed to learn the results of a study published recently in Learning and Behavior. It determined that “[t]here is no current case for canine exceptionalism” and, in reality, dogs are pretty ordinary compared to other “carnivores, domestic animals, and social hunters” like wolves, chimpanzees, and cats. What’s more, dogs aren’t at the top of the charts when it comes to sensing human emotions. The article linked above notes:
“Even more surprising, dogs do not appear to be exceptional in their ability to perceive and use communicative signals from humans. According to the domestication hypothesis, dogs have been bred to be especially sensitive to human cues such as hand signals. As Lea and Osthaus note, dogs can indeed use human cues. However, contrary to the domestication hypothesis, they are far from unique in this ability. For example, the reigning champions of the ability to follow human hand signals are the bottlenose dolphin and the grey seal.”
So why does everybody other than Lab owners think their dog is intellectually gifted? It’s called the Lake Woebegon Effect. Everybody thinks that they — and their pets, too — are above average. The article notes: “In a study published in Basic and Applied Social Psychology, researchers had 137 pet owners rate both their own pet and the average pet on a range of traits, including intelligence. The results revealed that the people rated their pets as above average on desirable traits and below average on undesirable traits.”
So, in all likelihood your dog isn’t a wunderkind. So what? They’re good company, they willingly will sport funny hats, and scientific studies also show that people who have dogs may enjoy health benefits from the companionship they provide. Our canine pals may not be geniuses, but they’re good to have around.