Today is the day the College Football Playoff Selection Committee earns its keep.
They’ve been watching games all season, and since mid-season they’ve been issuing interim rankings after each weekend of play. But now the regular season games and the conference championship games are done, and it’s time to finally decide: which four teams should be in this year’s playoff?
Alabama is in, of course, as the number one seed. They romped through a pretty pathetic SEC without a loss and drubbed an offensively challenged Florida team in the SEC championship game. That’s an easy call. But who else do you select? One-loss Clemson won the weak ACC, edging out a pretty one-dimensional Virginia Tech team in last night’s championship game, and has looked good at times but bad at times, too. One-loss Washington played one of the easiest schedules in college football and won the PAC 12, beating up a hapless Colorado team in the championship game. Oklahoma, with two losses, won the defensively challenged Big 12.
And then there’s the Big 10. Ohio State played one of the toughest schedules in college football, smashed Big 12 champion Oklahoma on its home turf, and beat a series of top ten teams during the season, including winning a thrilling edition of The Game against Michigan. But because Ohio State lost at Penn State, on a blocked field goal in the fourth quarter, the Buckeyes didn’t play for the conference championship. Penn State did and won last night, coming from far behind to beat Wisconsin. But the Nittany Lions have two losses, one of which was a 39-point thrashing at the hands of That Team Up North.
So who should join Alabama in the playoffs? The dedicated members of Buckeye Nation obviously hope the Committee selects Ohio State, which was ranked number 2 after last week’s Committee vote. Should the Committee just pick the one-loss teams from the Power Five conferences, which means Ohio State, Clemson, and Washington should make the cut? Or should Penn State’s impressive run and conference championship knock out one of those teams? But how do you vault the two-loss Nittany Lions above two-loss Michigan, which beat Penn State like a drum early in the season?
Ohio State fans are wishing, and hoping, that the Buckeyes make the cut. Having watched a number of games with the top teams, I honestly think Ohio State is one of the top four teams — but I’m not on the committee. We’ll know at 12:30.
Tomorrow we’ll see the finale of HBO’s Westworld. We’re being assured that all will be revealed, and after the episode the show will actually make sense.
Yeah, right! I’ll believe it when I see it. That’s like expecting triumphant Trump staffers and bitter Clinton campaign operatives to reach friendly consensus on why Donald Trump won the election, or imagining that fair-minded Michigan fans will freely concede that the referees correctly spotted the ball on the 15-yard line after J.T. Barrett’s fourth-down keeper in the second overtime of this year’s classic version of The Game.
Westworld is right up there with The Leftovers as the most confusing show since Twin Peaks. It’s so intentionally mystifying that I don’t even try to understand it, or piece together the disparate threads of the plot. I just wince at the horribly bloody violence that is likely to occur at any tender moment, groan at the show’s troubling core assumption that any human who goes to a fantasy world will promptly turn into a blood-soaked, sex-crazed lunatic, and recognize that any character in the next instant could be revealed as a robot, a cold-blooded killer, a psychopath, or all three. (I also cringe for the actors who have to routinely sit buck naked on chairs on a sterile set while other characters question them and tap iPads, but that’s another story.)
I’ve stopped trying to figure it all out. Kish and I watch the show, and I just let it kind of wash over me, rather than struggling to make sense of why Dolores’ outfit changes from instant to instant or why Bernard’s interactions with his fake dead son are so significant. I realized that the show had reached the point of ridiculousness this past week, when I was walking back from lunch with two friends, one of whom watches Westworld and one of whom doesn’t. The watcher and I started talking about the show, and after a few minutes of discussion of “Billy” and the possibility that the show’s plot is running along different timelines and the importance of the photo of Billy’s bethrothed and whether the twitching beings at the church Dolores visited were troubled robots looking for some kind of salvation, the non-watcher asked, with a baffled laugh: “What is this show?” And I realized that it was all pretty silly.
So I’ll watch the finale, but I’m not expecting that I’ll get everything in this episode, because that sure hasn’t been the case in the past episodes. I just make one request: before we move on to “the new narrative,” can you at least let us know what the old narrative was all about?
Look, there have been a lot of incredible Ohio State-Michigan games over the years. Virtually every game between the two fierce rivals during the ’70s was a tough, hard-hitting advertisement for why college football is the greatest sport there is. There was the Snow Bowl, and the 2006 match-up between two teams ranked no. 1 and no.2, and — giving the devil its due — Michigan’s legendary 1969 upset of an Ohio State team that many at the time considered to be the best college football team ever.
So I’m not going to say that yesterday’s double-overtime thriller was the best Ohio State-Michigan game ever played — but I am going to say that it was an epic contest that was simply one of the best college football games I’ve ever seen. Two strong teams with shutdown defenses. Wild emotional swings. Missed field goals and turnovers. Officiating controversy. A gutsy call that blew up in the coach’s face, and then a gutsy call that produced the game-winning touchdown. It’s the stuff of legend; an instant classic that people will remember and talk about for years to come. No one who watched it, in the stands or on TV, will forget the 2016 edition of The Game.
And in the end, Ohio State won, and Michigan went home crushed. Michigan’s head coach, Jim Harbaugh, blames the referees for the loss, saying they missed a spot and blew some pass interference calls. His disappointment is understandable, because his team played a great game and seemed to have The Game in hand until Ohio State’s defense ground the Michigan offense down and the Buckeyes’ offense finally woke up. Still, it’s too bad that such a great game should end with such sour grapes. Coach Harbaugh’s comments seem to cheapen The Game, and that’s too bad.
Ohio State’s unfortunate mishaps against Penn State mean that the Buckeyes once again won’t play in the Big Ten championship game. Instead, they will have to wait to see whether they are selected for this year’s college football playoff, and Ohio State fans will keep their fingers crossed that the selection committee recognizes that the Buckeyes are one of the four best teams in the land.
For now, though, we can just savor an epic win against the Wolverines, and reflect on the fact that beating That Team from Up North never gets old.
In a stunning upset, Bernie Sanders won the Democratic primary in Michigan last night, narrowly beating Hillary Clinton and delighting those unnamed members of the Webner household who have felt the Bern and are supporting the Sanders campaign.
It was a shocking victory, because the polls prior to the Michigan primary had shown that Hillary Clinton was way ahead in Michigan, by as much as 20 percentage points, and the pundits had already chalked up the state as falling into the Clinton win column. But the polls were wrong — obviously — and now the pundits and pollsters are wondering whether there are some fundamental errors in their polling metrics and identification of likely voters. They are uncomfortably considering whether the fact that polls were so wrong in Michigan might mean that the polling data in similar Midwestern states, like Ohio and Illinois, might also be way off base. The polls in those states are showing Hillary Clinton currently holds big leads heading into primaries that will be held next week.
Sanders’ upset win is richly satisfying — not because I’m a Sanders supporter or Hillary hater, but because I’m sick to death of how the news media now uses polling data and know-it-all pronouncements to drive a horse race narrative and prematurely pick the winner, rather than just reporting on what the candidates are saying and doing and letting the voters decide. The pollsters and pundits have long since declared Hillary Clinton the presumptive Democratic nominee and have talked, talked, talked about when Sanders will be forced to get out of the race, but the voters in Michigan had something different to say about it and thumbed their noses at the Beltway crowd in the process. Good for them!
Bernie Sanders obviously touches a chord with some voters that Hillary Clinton simply cannot reach. Does his win in Michigan mean he might pull off an upset here in Ohio? I don’t know, but I will say that I have personally seen a lot more excitement and activity in the Sanders campaign than I have from the Clinton campaign. In Michigan, Sanders crushed Clinton among younger voters, made significant inroads with African-American voters, and appealed to Democrats who are fed up with their economic circumstances. Ohio isn’t quite in the same shape as Michigan, but many of the same issues are present, and there’s no reason to believe Sanders can’t do the same thing here.
I’m hoping that Bernie Sander’s Michigan shocker means the pundits will stop with their confident pronouncements about what is going to happen, in Ohio and elsewhere, based on polling data that might just be fundamentally flawed. Perhaps, just perhaps, they will be content to actually let the voters vote now that the race moves to the Buckeye State.
Evan Turner — improbably nicknamed The Villain by teammate Mark Titus — came back to Ohio State tonight to see his jersey retired and hung from the rafters. Turner had a storied career with the Buckeyes, won National Player of the Year honors, and made a killer three-point buzzer-beater to beat Michigan in the Big Ten Tournament. Tonight he gave a heartfelt speech about his teammates, his coaches, and especially his Mom helping him along the way.
Oh, and the Buckeyes beat the Wolverines, too. A good time was had by all.
Look, I know a lot of pundits and Ohio State fans are at the point where the Buckeyes have to win every game by 50 points and win the national championship, or the season is deemed a failure. I think that’s ridiculous, but it is what it is.
This was a great season, by any rational measure. If you are an Ohio State fan, you define season success by whether you beat Michigan. This year, the Buckeyes trounced the Wolverines, in Ann Arbor. Michigan was a darned good team — they smashed an SEC team, Florida, in their bowl game today. And then Ohio State won its bowl game today, convincingly beating a very solid Notre Dame team in the Fiesta Bowl. Those of us who lived through the Cooper era will never forget it, and will always treasure every win against That Team Up North and bowl game opponents because we will always remember, with a grimace, what it is like to end a season with a painful belly flop.
People are upset because Ohio State lost one game, played in a driving rainstorm, on a last-second field goal. But when your team finishes 12-1, wins its crucial rivalry game and pounds a traditional power in a New Years Day bowl game, you can’t fairly be heard to complain. If you do, you’re really as spoiled as the appalling Affluenza Kid.
A lot of Buckeyes have made the last few years really enjoyable for those of us in Buckeye Nation and will (in some cases probably) be moving on. Thanks, Braxton Miller! And Joey Bosa. Ezekiel Elliott. Cardale Jones. Taylor Decker. Adolphus Washington. Joshua Perry. Jacoby Boren. Other seniors who have won 50 games in their four years. And, perhaps, some other juniors who think it’s time to take their talents to the NFL. They have accomplished everything you could ask for, and I will always remember cheering myself hoarse and screaming “ZEEEEEKE” as last year’s national championship game wound down and I got to celebrate a year where my team and many of these same players and coaches won it all.
Thanks, guys, to all of the players, to head coach Urban Meyer and the rest of the coaching staff, and to everybody else who is part of the Ohio State football program. It’s been a pleasure, and today was the cherry on top.