In 2021, in the name of criminal justice reform, California enacted a new law to prohibit police departments from posting “mug shot” photos on social media platforms of suspects apprehended for non-violent crimes. In 2023, California expanded the law by requiring police departments to remove any mug shots of suspects from social media accounts after 14 days. Both requirements took effect this year.
The police department in Murrieta, California–located about halfway between Los Angeles and San Diego–has taken a novel approach to compliance with the new law. It’s posting “mug shot” photos of suspects, but obscuring their actual heads with “Lego” heads. Examples of the results–which are curious, to say the least–are shown above.
Why post Lego head photos of suspects apprehended for non-violent crimes? As quoted in the Los Angeles Times article linked above, a Murrieta police department spokesman explained: “The Murrieta Police Department prides itself in its transparency with the community, but also honors everyone’s rights & protections as afforded by law; even suspects. In order to share what is happening in Murrieta, we chose to cover the faces of suspects to protect their identity while still aligning with the new law.”
The Times article quotes a professor of sociology and criminology at Cal Poly Pomona, who argues that publishing Lego head mug shots really doesn’t serve the need for transparency, and seems to be an effort to mock and dehumanize arrested suspects and damage their reputations. That concern seems overblown to me, however. Since the faces are totally obscured, the general public won’t be able to identify the suspects, and therefore their reputations aren’t really at risk. And publishing photos of captured suspects, even with Lego heads, does serve a transparency purpose–it shows the Murrieta residents, and would-be non-violent criminals, that the Murrieta police department is doing its job. A picture of two captured suspects, handcuffed and deposited in the back of a patrol car, has an impact that the dry textual reporting of an apprehension just can’t match.
I understand the impetus of the California law, because it helps to fully implement the notion that people are innocent until proven guilty, but it seems to me that the Murrieta police department has found a clever way to comply with the law yet still provide meaningful information about public safety issues to residents. And if the creative use of Lego heads makes more people pay attention to the social media postings of the Murrieta police about what they’re doing to deal with crime in their community, is that really a bad thing?