If you needed further proof that modern America has become a weird place, consider the strange dynamic that was supposed to put two of the richest men in the world, Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg, into a “cage match” for a mixed martial arts fight. Now it looks like that misguided event isn’t going to come off, perhaps because Elon Musk has come to his senses and questions why in the world he would want to get involved in a punch-out with anyone–much less the billionaire CEO of Facebook.
The talk of fisticuffs isn’t limited to social media tycoons. Recently former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, who is running for the 2024 GOP nomination for President, was asked who would win if he got into the ring with former President Donald Trump. Christie gleefully responded: “I’d kick his ass.” It’s not clear why the interviewer, Piers Morgan, raised the possibility of fisticuffs between a morbidly obese 60-year-old and an overweight near-octogenarian, provoking painful mental images for anyone who thought about that ugly scenario. But Christie wasn’t the first modern politician to raise the possibility of a physical encounter; his comment was reminiscent of an earlier dust-up between President Joe Biden and Trump about going out behind the high school gym for a brawl.
It’s interesting to think about why political and social leaders talk in these kinds of juvenile terms. I don’t remember the politicians or wealthy businessmen of my youth boasting about duking it out with opponents. To the contrary, hot-headedness was viewed as a negative quality at a time when an ill-considered decision in the Cold War setting could lead to nuclear armageddon. Whether in the business world or in the political arena, the idea was to be seen as cool, calm, and calculated, ready to out-maneuver and outwit your opponent and keep your head while everyone around you was reduced to blubbering panic–not as an angry, loud-mouthed street brawler ready to take a swing at the slightest provocation.
The world still seems like a very dangerous place to me, where those same attributes of calmness in crisis are crucial–but obviously perceptions have changed. Do current leaders mistake physical toughness for mental toughness? Do they feel they need to talk about fighting to break through the din and convey to their supporters that they really care? For whatever reason, it’s disturbing to hear political and social leaders acting like physical violence is a way to solve anything. Where’s the likes of Dwight Eisenhower or Adlai Stevenson these days?